Dungeon Classics #35: Sin City

FilmDungeon’s Chief Editor JK sorts through the Dungeon’s DVD-collection to look for old cult favorites….

Sin City (2005, USA)

Director: Robert Rodriguez
Cast: Mickey Rourke, Clive Owen, Bruce Willis, Jessica Alba
Running Time: 124 mins.

The cinematic masterpiece Sin City weaves together three interconnected hard-boiled mysteries filled with sex, blood, and violence, all set in the criminal haven of Basin City. With its noir-inspired silhouettes of men in long coats, gravelly voiceovers revealing inner thoughts, and splashes of color that contrast with the shadowy streets, every frame of this film is a visual feast. Each of the three stories revolves around tough, beautiful women with big hearts who find themselves in serious danger, aided by male loners. Bruce Willis plays Hartigan, an aging cop with a bad heart who is determined to protect young Nancy from a sadistic, murderous pedophile. Mickey Rourke portrays Marv, a psychopathic brute made of concrete, who fights on the side of good as he seeks revenge on the men who killed Goldie, a prostitute who gave him the night of his life. Clive Owen is Dwight, a mysterious figure who helps the women of Old Town cover up the murder of a corrupt cop, staving off a potentially bloody conflict. Robert Rodriguez’s adaptation of Frank Miller’s iconic comic series is one of the most successful graphic novel-to-screen translations in cinematic history. Shot and edited by Rodriguez himself, it’s a remarkable technical achievement. But the film’s brilliance doesn’t stop at the visuals, its cast and screenplay are equally stellar. Miller’s sharp, punchy dialogue, already compelling on the page, is brought to life perfectly by an ensemble of outstanding actors: Jessica Alba, Mickey Rourke, Bruce Willis, Rosario Dawson, Benicio Del Toro, Rutger Hauer, Alexis Bledel, Elijah Wood, Michael Madsen, Brittany Murphy, and Clive Owen. The performances elevate the material into something extraordinary. Without a doubt, Sin City is Rodriguez’s finest work to date. It’s a true work of cinematic art.

Dungeon Classics #31: 300

300 (2006, USA, Canada, Bulgaria)

Director: Zack Snyder
Cast: Gerard Butler, Lena Headey, David Wenham, Dominic West
Running Time: 117 mins.

One year after the visually stunning Sin City, another Frank Miller comic book was brought to life and it also became an incredible visual spectacle. 300 is eye candy of the best sort; filled with spear thrusts, pierced bodies, beheadings, mounting horses, rainfalls of arrows – all shot through beautiful filters in terrific slow motion. There isn’t much of a story to be told; this is just pure macho shit. A bunch (300) of muscular Spartan warriors refuse to be overruled by Persian God king Xerxes, so they march to war, commanded by their stout king Leonidas (Gerard Butler in his breakthrough role) and supported by his formidable queen (played by a pre-Game of Thrones Lena Headey). What follows is bloodletting on a grand scale. The custom design, make-up, camerawork and editing/post production are all top notch. What has happened to this visual style since then? Zack Snyder has since made quite a few successful superhero epics, like Justice League and Men of Steel, but 300 remains his most accomplished work.

Cannibalism Now!

In Cannibal Holocaust from 1980, a four-headed film crew heads into the Amazon jungle to shoot a documentary about cannibalism. They never return. When their cans of film are found later on, the gruesome truth about their faiths is uncovered. The film has been extremely controversial since its release and is still banned in several countries. Cannibal Holocaust remains a very unpleasant viewing today due its nauseatingly realistic scenes of violence and mutilation. Still, the shocking subject matter seems to have a certain appeal on many people. What is it with cannibalism that fascinates people so much and how is this fascination translated into cinema?

In Western civilization, cannibalism is considered as something perverted, disgusting, extremely primitive, sick and demented. In most countries there is not even a law against cannibalism. Whenever an occasional case of cannibalism does come to light, the perpetrator is mostly convicted of another act such as murder or necrophilia. The eating of individuals from the same species does still occur, but it happens very marginally. The fact that it still happens means that it is definitely human. We can only admit to this repressed fascination by engaging in fantasy. Through books, music and – off course – movies we can come to terms with the cannibal inside of us.

Cannibals in cinema go back a long time. As far as I can tell, the first movie that features cannibalism is the short Queenie and the Cannibal from 1912. It is the beginning of a very long list. Last century alone, 90 movies premiered with the notion ‘cannibalism’ in the title. Movies that feature the theme cannibalism encompass several genres and subgenres. Very often they are horrors, adventures or crossovers. Mostly, they are also exploitation and sexploitation flicks (or straight out porn). Many can also be classified as racist – as natives are portrayed as savage flesh eaters. Some examples of these types of cannibal movies include; Emanuelle and the Last Cannibals (1977), The Mountain of the Cannibal God (1978), Cannibal Ferox (1981), The Flesh (1991) and Diary of a Cannibal (2007). Human’s fascination with the subject is also translated into the zombie film. After all, despite the fact that they are dead, zombies are still humans that eat other human’s flesh.

Exploitation films that deal with cannibalism are often horrors, but there are quite a lot of comedies as well. Ivan Reitman’s second feature film is the Canadian comedy-horror Cannibal Girls about three beautiful young women who lure men with their seductive charm to their home in order to kill and eat them. By drinking their blood and eating their flesh the women maintain their youthfulness and immortality. Eating Raoul is a 1982 black comedy in which cannibalism is used for the central gag. Another black comedy and horror is Motel Hell (1980) about a farmer / hotel owner who makes meat products with special ingredients. Auntie Lee’s Meat Pies (1992) already tells you all you need to know with its title and Trey Parker from South Park made Cannibal! The Musical (1993) in his college days. This blend of comedy, biography and musical is loosely based on the history of Alfred ‘Alferd’ Packer who was convicted for cannibalism in 1874.

While Italians can often be credited for nasty exploitation cannibal films, the French are largely responsible for putting cannibals in the Art House. A Taste For Woman (1964) is a black comedy by French director Jean Leon from an adapted screenplay by Roman Polanski. This is about a vegetarian restaurant that acts as cover for a sect that eats women as part of a full moon ceremony. Jean-Luc Godards Week End (1967) shows the savage journey of a bourgeois couple through France. They eventually fall prey to hippy cannibals. In Delicatessen (1991) by Marc Caro and Jean-Pierre Jeunet a butcher / landlord sells human flesh to his odd tenants in a post-apocalyptic world. Finally Les amants criminels (1999, François Ozon) is a thriller that retells the Hansel and Gretel legend, only with the wicked witch replaced by a woodsman with cannibalistic tendencies.

While the Art House and Grindhouse cinemas have had their taste of cannibalism, mainstream Hollywood has also exploited the theme for big time box-office return. The Silence of the Lambs was a sleeper hit in 1991, and its main star Hannibal ‘The Cannibal’ Lecter, portrayed by Anthony Hopkins, returned in Hannibal (2001) and Red Dragon (2002). Especially the first sequel has scenes of explicit cannibalism in it, just look at the scene in which Lecter feeds on Ray Liotta’s brains. In Sin City (2005), the mute serial killer Kevin (Elijah Wood) kills prostitutes, mounts their heads on a wall like hunting trophies and cannibalizes their remains, feeding the leftovers to his pet wolf.

Not a Hollywood film, but immensely popular was The Texas Chain Saw Massacre in 1974. In it, a group of friends stumble upon a family of cannibals in rural Texas. The film was made independently by director Tobe Hooper for just around 140.000 dollars. Due to its graphic content, the film was banned in several countries, but did make 30.8 million dollars at the U.S. box office alone. It got five sequels and a remake in 2003. A quite similar film is The Hills Have Eyes, which is a cult classic directed by Wes Craven in 1977. The story revolves around a family of mutant cannibals that prey on a family who have been stranded in the Nevada desert. In 1991, Craven also made The People Under the Stairs about a psychotic and cannibalistic couple played by Everett McGill and Wendy Robie who also played a couple in Twin Peaks. They ‘keep’ people between the walls of their house and eat the occasional liver.

While Cannibal Holocaust and The Texas Chainsaw Massacre only pretend to be based on reality, there are also real real-life stories about cannibalism that have been turned into movies. Think about Grimm Love aka Rohtenburg. This movie is based on the true story of self-confessed cannibal Armin Meiwes and the ‘internet cannibal movement’. In March 2001 Meiwes killed and partially ate a man he had met on the internet. The eating was based on a mutual agreement. The movie was banned in Germany after Meiwes filed a complaint against it. True cannibalism is also found in Alive (1993). This film tells the story of the Uruguayan national rugby teams’ plane that crashed in the middle of the Andes Mountains in 1972. The survivors have to take desperate measures to stay alive, including eating their deceived friends and family members.

Except for voluntary cannibalism there are also quite a few examples of people who force or trick people into eating other humans. Look no further than The Cook, the Thief, His Wife & Her Lover (1989) and Titus (1999) based on a play by William Shakespeare. There is also Jennifer’s Body (2009), starring Megan Fox and Amanda Seyfried and written by Oscar winning screenplay writer Diablo Cody. In it, Megan Fox plays a high school beauty queen who eats her boyfriends.

Judging from this overview, movies that feature cannibalism come in many forms and vary strongly in quality. Compared to food, they range from the cheapest junk to the highest culinary achievement. Either way, the theme has successfully manifested itself into cinema and still fascinates people to this day and will undoubtedly continue to do so in the future.

Mijn 10 favoriete comics & graphic novels

10. The Punisher

Over the Punisher – oftewel Frank Castle, de ex politieman die maffiosi afslacht als wraak voor de dood van zijn familie – zijn vele boeken gemaakt, maar de uitgave van MAX-comics (onderdeel van Marvel) uit 2004 van schrijver Garth Ennis is een hoogtepunt. Het eerste deel gaat over Castle’s bloederige tijd in Vietnam, en in de delen daarna neemt hij het als vanouds op tegen de maffia en later de IRA. Een heftige, woeste en extreem gewelddadige comic.

09. Star Wars

De personages, werelden, voertuigen en ruimteschepen van Star Wars lenen zich perfect voor het stripmedium. Nu zijn er ontelbaar veel (strip)boeken verschenen van het Star Wars Expended Universe, maar de stripversies van de heilige trilogie van Marvel zijn de enige die er voor mij echt toe doen. Perfectere verhalen zul je nergens anders aantreffen en de tekenkunst van deze boeken is werkelijk onovertroffen. Bovendien voegen de dialogen en vertelteksten nog wat details toe die niet in de films zitten. Droom dus lekker weg met Luke Skywalker, Yoda en Darth Vader in de beste trilogie ooit gecreëerd, niet alleen in science fiction, maar in alle genres.

08. Criminal

Criminal’ (2006) is een veel geprezen misdaadserie van Ed Brubaker en Sean Phillips; er zijn inmiddels zeven boeken van uitgebracht. Het zijn losse verhalen, maar vele plaatsen en karakters uit de misdaadwereld komen vaker langs. De verhalen zijn vlijmscherp en de kunst is uniek; het laat zich nergens mee vergelijken. ‘Criminal’ leent zich perfect voor een verfilming, maar of die ooit komt of niet; de boeken zijn zeer zeer zeer goed te pruimen.

07. Transmetropolitan

De toekomstige aarde in sci-fi strip ‘Transmetropolitan’ is een sociale beestenbende vol met freaky hightech shit, zoals mensen omgevormd tot alien-ras, bevroren hoofden tot leven gewekt met nanotechnologie en gedownloade geesten in onsterfelijke wolkachtige verschijningen. In deze wereld zoekt Gonzo-journalist Spider Jerusalem (gebaseerd op Hunter S. Thompson, maar een onvergetelijk karakter op zichzelf) naar rechtvaardigheid. Wanneer pure waanzin aanvoelt als een accuraat beeld van de 23ste eeuw weet je dat de schrijvers/tekenaars iets wezenlijks te pakken hebben. Van deze cult-klassieker verschenen tien hardcover uitgaven ieder bestaande uit zes (meestal op zichzelf staande) verhalen.

06. Watchmen

Alan Moore’s extreem ambitieuze en complexe graphic novel zet de wereld van superhelden compleet op zijn kop. De helden in dit verhaal, dat zich afspeelt ten tijden van de Koude Oorlog, zijn alles behalve feilloos. In 2009 werd ‘Watchmen’ uitstekend verfilmd door Zack Snyder (‘300’), maar de prachtige blauwe huid van de goddelijke Dr. Manhattan ziet er toch het beste uit op de geprinte pagina. Een must-read.

05. Maus

Het waargebeurde levensverhaal van holocaust overlever Vladek Spiegelman – vader van de schrijver/tekenaar van ‘Maus’ – weet diep te ontroeren. De vorm is daarnaast de origineelste ooit. Alle personages zijn dieren: de Joden zijn muizen en de Duitsers zijn katten. De Amerikanen zijn honden en de Polen, dat zijn varkens. Maar ondanks hun dierlijke verschijningsvorm zijn ze allemaal zeer… menselijk. En dat is soms fijn en soms uiterst verontrustend. De wrede onmenselijke horror gebeurtenissen in onder meer Auschwitz komen namelijk ook uitgebreid aan bod en in beeld. Wie zou denken dat een strip in deze vorm zich zo goed zou lenen voor een Holocaust overlevingsverhaal?

04. Batman: The Killing Joke

De ultieme comic book villain krijgt zijn eigen meesterlijke en iconische graphic novel van DC Comics. In het losstaande verhaal uit 1988, geschreven door Alan Moore en geïllustreerd door Brian Bolland, probeert de clown prins van de misdaad te bewijzen dat onder bepaalde omstandigheden iedereen waanzinnig wordt, zelfs zijn aartsvijanden aan de andere kant van de wet: Batman en commissaris Gordon. In zijn meedogenloze plan ontziet hij niets en niemand en dat leidt tot taferelen van ongekende gruwelijkheid en waanzin. Moore en Bolland creëerde met ‘The Killing Joke’ een klassieker, een absoluut meesterwerk in de stripkunst.



03. Sin City

Frank Miller’s sublieme noir verhalen zijn zowel qua inhoud als stijl briljant neergezet. De innerlijke worstelingen van ruige karakters in een wereld bevolkt door moordenaars en prostituees zijn perfect gevat in de (innerlijke) monologen. Verwacht geen genade in deze duistere verhalen over de gevaarlijke fictieve stad ‘Basin City’. In totaal verschenen er zeven delen in de serie (zes verhalen en één boek met gebundelde short stories). De eerste ‘The Hard Goodbye’ met Marv als hoofdpersonage (in de verfilming gespeeld door Mickey Rourke) is nog altijd de beste.

02. Lone Wolf & Cub

Deze Japanse manga klassieker – waarin een samoerai huurmoordenaar door het land trekt met zijn zoontje – werd succesvol verfilmd, maar de 28-delige stripserie is een kunstwerk dat in de geniaal geïllustreerde zwart-wit pagina’s het beste tot zijn recht komt. Schrijver Kazuo Koike en illustrator Goseki Kojima brengen niet alleen de gewelddadige actie op unieke wijze in beeld, maar weten ook diep te ontroeren met de onbreekbare band tussen vader en zoon. De combinatie van bloederige Japanse geschiedenis, Oosterse filosofie, kinetische actie en de tragedie van de verhalen maken dit tot een waar stripmeesterwerk.

01. Storm

‘Storm’ is dé strip waar ik mee opgroeide. De avonturen van de iconische helden Storm, Roodhaar en Nomad heb ik eindeloos herlezen en ze blijven fenomenaal. Gek genoeg is Storm alleen bekend in Nederland en het Verenigd Koninkrijk; de kwaliteit is makkelijk hoog genoeg om internationaal door te breken. Sterker nog, het is briljant. De Britse tekenaar Don Lawrence wist de intelligente science fiction verhalen van de verschillende schrijvers als schilderijen op de pagina’s te toveren. Met ‘De Armageddon Reiziger’ (2001) sloot hij de serie af (dit was deel 22 in de serie). Na zijn overlijden is de draad weer opgepikt, maar voor mij blijven zijn Storms de enige echte. Ware klassiekers die de stripkunst op het niveau van de beste literatuur weten te brengen.