Dungeon Classics #48: Barton Fink

FilmDungeon’s Chief Editor JK sorts through the Dungeon’s DVD-collection to look for old cult favorites….

Barton Fink (1991, UK, USA)

Director: Joel Coen, Ethan Coen
Cast: John Turturro, John Goodman, Judy Davis, Michael Lerner
Running Time: 116 mins.

When the Coen Brothers hit writer’s block while working on Miller’s Crossing, they took a break and wrote Barton Fink: a story about a playwright who suffers from writer’s block. After finishing Miller’s Crossing, they moved on to this film, starring two Johns: John Turturro as the titular character and John Goodman as his hotel neighbour. Barton Fink has success with Bare Ruined Choirs, a play about the common man. He’s offered 2,000 dollars a week to work in Hollywood, and with that decision he sells his soul to the devil. He’s assigned to write a wrestling picture, but isolated in his hotel room, he can’t get a single word out of his typewriter. Turturro is terrific as the pompous Fink, who pretends to be a champion of the common man yet fails to listen to one when he finally meets one in the flesh: his next-door neighbour, Charlie Meadows. The film quickly develops an eerie, almost horror-like mood, while still delivering plenty of classic Coen Brothers humour. Barton’s haircut is so high it almost fills half the screen, the studio head (a scene-stealing, Oscar-nominated performance by Michael Lerner) literally kisses Barton’s feet, and Barton is forced to watch dailies of the most terrible wrestling movie ever made. The story unfolds like a nightmare in which Barton gets trapped in his hotel room and inside his own mind, which he doesn’t understand. The film famously won the Palme d’Or, Best Director, and Best Actor at Cannes 1991, the first film ever to sweep the top three prizes, a feat that sparked controversy at the time.

06. Miller’s Crossing (1990)

Director: Joel Coen
Writers: Joel Coen, Ethan Coen
Stars: Gabriel Byrne, Albert Finney, John Turturro, Jon Polito

This review is part of the feature:

The 33 Gangster Films You Can’t Refuse

Miller’s Crossing is another great one from the prime gangster film year 1990 and second best from that year according to me and Ethan Coen, who once generously confessed that he thought GoodFellas was better.

Miller’s Crossing is stylistically based on Dashiell Hammett’s novels The Glass Key and Red Harvest and tells the story of Irish crime boss Leo O’Bannion (Albert Finney) and his gambling addicted Nr. 2 Tom Reagan (Gabriel Byrne) who rule over an unnamed American city in the 1930’s.

They enter into a conflict with Italian competitor Johnny Caspar (Jon Polito) and his lethal henchman Eddie Dane (J.E. Freeman) over the unreliable bookie Bernie Bernbaum (John Turturro) who Caspar wants to kill and Leo protects.

When a gang war erupts, Tom and Leo’s friendship gets strained over a woman (Verna, played by Marcia Gay Harden) and Tom joins Caspar’s gang. But to what end?

Many scenes in Miller’s Crossing are reminiscent of The Godfather, but Coen Brother style which means darkly comical and at times outright bizarre, but also brilliantly executed.

The complex screenplay is an ingenious piece of work. Famously, the brothers got a writing block while penning it, so they took a break to write their next movie Barton Fink, which is about a screenplay writer with a terrible case of writing block. Then they returned to Miller’s Crossing and I think it became one of their best screenplays; full of hard boiled dialogue and layered characters.

The casting is also great. Gabriel Byrne was never better as the headstrong and principled Tom. All of the supporting cast members are excellent as well in equal measure. And the thrilling camerawork (lot’s of riding and swooping camera moves) seems to be inspired by the Coen’s best friend Sam Raimi who plays an amusing bit part in this film.

There are also lots of hats in this movie, but they don’t really mean anything.

Double Bill #18: Fargo & A Simple Plan

Few films share as much in common as Fargo and A Simple Plan. Both unfold in the snowy, desolate landscapes of Minnesota, steeped in an atmosphere that feels as bleak as it is gripping. Thematically, they explore the destructive power of greed – how a single, flawed decision can spiral into violence, ruin lives, and reveal the darkness lurking within ordinary people. The connection between the films extends beyond their themes. The Coen Brothers, directors of Fargo, and Sam Raimi, who helmed A Simple Plan, are longtime collaborators and friends. Both films are superb, but Fargo stands as a true masterpiece. Its razor-sharp original screenplay and unforgettable characters set it apart. The story centers on Jerry Lundegaard (William H. Macy), a pathetic and desperate car salesman who arranges the kidnapping of his own wife, hoping to extort ransom money from his wealthy father-in-law. When the sociopathic criminals he hires (Steve Buscemi and Peter Stormare) murder a state trooper and two witnesses, they draw the attention of the sharp, heavily pregnant Brainerd police chief Marge Gunderson – an Oscar-winning role from Frances McDormand. Nothing in Jerry’s plan goes right, and the consequences of his evil scheme are as brutal as they are inevitable. A Simple Plan follows a similarly grim trajectory. When three men stumble upon a crashed plane in the woods – containing a dead pilot and over four million dollars in cash – the seemingly level-headed Hank (Bill Paxton) agrees with his dim-witted brother Jacob (Billy Bob Thornton) and Jacob’s redneck friend Lou (Brent Briscoe) to hide the money until they can safely claim it. What starts as a simple scheme quickly unravels, forcing Hank into a series of horrific acts to protect their secret. Together, these films serve as chilling cautionary tales, illustrating how the pursuit of easy money can corrupt ordinary lives and destroy families.

Double Bill #12: The Big Lebowski & The Jesus Rolls

In the nineties the Coen Brothers rolled two strikes in a row with Fargo (1996) and The Big Lebowski (1998), two instant classics that both feature a kidnapping. Fargo is a bloody North Dakota-set crime story with humor that is darker than a black steer’s tookus on a moonless prairie night. The Big Lebowski is a Raymond Chandler-style mystery featuring a valued rug, bowling balls, white Russians and the question of what it means to be a man. I considered coupling them for this feature; in terms of bizarre characters, endlessly quotable dialogues and outrageous situations these movies certainly match, but for some reason I chose The Jesus Rolls (2019, dir: John Turturro) instead. Jesus Quintana (played by John Turturro) was one of the many memorable characters from The Big Lebowski and even though he was only in two scenes totaling less than six minutes in screen-time, he got his own movie. It’s as if Ned Ryerson would get his own flick two decades after Groundhog Day (Ned Ryerson Insures!). The Coens had nothing to do with it: but they gave John Turturrro permission to run with the character. It is both a spinoff and a remake of the French movie Going Places (1974), which was very controversial at the time for its vulgarity, depiction of sexual acts and amorality. The story revolves around a road trip taken by Quintana, Petey (Bobby Cannavale) and Marie (Audrey Tautou) during which they engage in sex and petty crime. Petey is an ex-convict like Jesus and Marie is what Maud Lebowski would call a nymphomaniac: a woman who engages in sex compulsively and without joy. The movie has one bowling scene and Jesus repeats some of his Lebowski lines, but the movie has nothing to do whatsoever with the events of The Big Lebowski (it even turns out that Jesus is not a pederast, he was only falsely accused of exposing himself to an eight year old). For a comedy it is not funny enough, and for a road movie it is too strange. But as a dessert after watching the masterpiece The Big Lebowski for the hundredth time, it is alright.